Compensation & Workforce Benchmarking

Private club compensation benchmarking, from the general manager to the dish steward

Pay your people fairly, budget payroll with confidence and give your Board a defensible answer. Club Benchmarking benchmarks compensation and benefits for more than 150 club positions, with three ways to put it to work: a Navigator Prime subscription, the new Workforce Profile, and an Executive Compensation Study for your Board.

Three ways to benchmark compensation

Put every compensation decision in market context

Whether you are making an offer to a line cook, setting the annual wage increase pool or reviewing your general manager’s contract, the question is the same: what does the market pay for this role at a club like ours? Pick the level of insight that fits the decision.

Navigator Prime

Benchmarks for 150+ positions

Self-serve compensation and benefits benchmarks for hourly and salaried roles, by position or by department, available 24/7 in VISTA.

What Prime includes

Coming soon · Summit

The Workforce Profile

Your club’s turnover, tenure, overtime and staffing mix benchmarked against peers, built from the Payroll Report you submit.

Preview the Workforce Profile

Advisory

Executive Compensation Study

A Board-ready report that benchmarks your general manager and executive team line by line, against peer sets the Board approves.

About the study

Why our compensation data

The private club industry’s largest compensation database

Clubs submit through a structured compensation and benefits worksheet or directly from payroll, so the figures reflect what clubs actually paid, not what someone recalled on a survey. Every comparison shows the number of clubs and respondents behind it, and no individual club’s compensation is ever disclosed.

150+
positions benchmarked, hourly and salaried
800
clubs in our Head of Club compensation sample
70%+
of the variation in Head of Club pay explained by club operating revenue
By position or departmentBenchmark a single role or an entire department, hourly or salaried.
Total compensationBase pay is only part of the story. Bonuses, allowances and benefits are measured too.
Benefits benchmarksHealth insurance and retirement plan benchmarks show how the full package compares.
Peer sets that fitCompare against clubs selected by size, location, amenity set and more.

Navigator Prime

Compensation and benefits benchmarks for 150+ positions

Prime is the Navigator plan built for clubs that benchmark the whole team, not just the top executives. From the front desk to the kitchen, see what peer clubs pay for the same role, by position or by department, and filter the comparison by size, location, amenity set and more.

150+ position benchmarks

Hourly and salaried positions across every department of the club, benchmarked by position or by department against the peer set you choose. Look up a single role before an offer, or review an entire department before budget season.

Health insurance and retirement plans

Health insurance plan and retirement plan benchmarks show how your benefits package compares, so the club measures total rewards, not just wages.

Staffing & Compensation dashboards

Dynamic dashboards and the Labor Report put payroll and staffing in context alongside the club’s finances and operations, so labor cost is never read in isolation.

Transparent comparisons

Every comparison shows how many clubs and total respondents are in the set, so you know the strength of each number before you take it to a committee.

Put it to work: set competitive offers for open roles, size the annual wage increase pool, build next year’s payroll budget and spot hard-to-fill positions where the club sits below market. On Essentials? Essentials includes compensation and benefits benchmarks for your top executives. Prime extends that to 150+ positions.

COMING SOONNew in Summit

The Workforce Profile: your club’s people data, side by side with your peers

Workforce data is more than an HR metric. It drives compensation planning, workforce stability, recruiting success and long-term financial performance. The Workforce Profile, a new addition to the Compensation & Benefits section of the platform, shows where your club stands and where to act.

Once your club submits its Payroll Report, these metrics are ready whenever you need them. No more pulling numbers together by hand, so you and your team can spend that time acting on them.

Executive Summary

Your most important workforce metrics at a glance.

Workforce Composition

How your staff is built and distributed across the club.

Tenure

Broken out by year-round full-time, year-round part-time and seasonal staff, so you can see the differences between them.

Retention Signals

How your workforce is turning over and where the ages of your staff currently lie.

Benchmarked KPIs include

Turnover rate less seasonal staff · Overtime as a percent of hours · Full Member Equivalents (FME) per Full Time Equivalent employee (FTE) · New hires retained six months or more · Total labor cost, turnover and overtime by department

Compare your way

Every KPI and graphic is measured against a peer set. Start with all clubs with Payroll Report data, then refine by geography, peer cluster, club type, total revenue and more. Toggle year-over-year change and switch between hourly and salaried staff.

Built from your Payroll Report. Clubs that have submitted a Payroll Report will see their data the day the profile goes live, and a prior-year submission unlocks the year-over-year views. Included with a Summit subscription at no additional cost.

Executive Compensation Study

Executive compensation your Board can defend to the membership

Compensation agreements are between the club and the staff member, not between a single Board and the staff member. An Executive Compensation Study gives the club a documented, data-based foundation that carries from one Board to the next. It benchmarks the Head of Club (General Manager, COO or CEO) and any other executive positions you choose, line item by line item, against peer sets built with your club. Choose the level of depth that fits the decision in front of you.

Full report, prepared for you

Executive Compensation Report

Your executive compensation benchmarks, built by our analysts into a complete report. Custom peer sets, line-item tables for every position with percentile rankings, and written analysis of where the club stands. Ideal for clubs that don’t subscribe to Navigator, or that would rather receive a finished report than run the benchmarks themselves.

For Board review

Advanced Compensation Study

Everything in the Executive Compensation Report, plus distribution graphics that plot your club against the full market and your peers, five scale and affordability measures that test whether each package fits the role’s scope, a narrative executive summary written for the Board, and a presentation of the findings to your Board.

Scale-controlled, not title-matchedClub Benchmarking’s regression analysis shows operating revenue explains more than 70% of the variation in Head of Club total compensation, so every study controls for the size of the operation.
Peer sets you can seeA revenue-banded view of the national market plus at least one named peer set, agreed before any analysis runs, with every peer club listed by name.
Line-item detailBase wage, bonuses, allowances, 401(k), 403(b), 457(b), 457(f) and life insurance, each ranked against the 10th, 25th, median, 75th and 90th percentiles.

Which option fits

Choose the right level of compensation insight

Many clubs use more than one: Prime for everyday hiring and budgeting, the Workforce Profile to track stability and retention, and an Executive Compensation Study when the Board reviews the leadership team.

Navigator PrimeWorkforce ProfileExecutive Compensation Study
AnswersWhat do peer clubs pay for this role?How stable and efficient is our workforce compared to peers?Is our executive compensation appropriate for our scale, and what is our policy?
Covers150+ hourly and salaried positions, plus health insurance and retirement plansTurnover, tenure, overtime, staffing mix and labor cost by departmentHead of Club plus any executive positions you choose, line item by line item
Best forClub managers, HR and finance leadersClub managers, HR directors and department headsBoards, Presidents and compensation committees
FormatSelf-serve benchmarks and dashboards in VISTA, 24/7Interactive KPIs and graphics in VISTAExecutive Compensation Report, or the Advanced Compensation Study with distribution graphics and a Board presentation
How to get itNavigator Prime or Summit planIncluded with Summit (coming soon)Scoped engagement

Solutions by role: Club managers · CFOs & controllers · Boards of directors · Owners & management companies

Common questions

Private club compensation, explained

How much should a private club pay its general manager?

It depends most on the size and complexity of the operation. Club Benchmarking’s research shows operating revenue explains more than 70% of the variation in Head of Club total compensation, so a credible benchmark compares your club to clubs of similar scale rather than simply matching titles or locations.

Does location drive executive pay at clubs?

Less than most Boards assume. Our published whitepapers find that executive compensation aligns with national market forces, and that cost of living contributes only marginally once club size is taken into account.

Which positions can my club benchmark?

Navigator Prime and Summit include compensation and benefits benchmarks for more than 150 hourly and salaried positions, by position or by department. The Essentials plan covers top executives.

Is our club’s compensation data kept confidential?

Yes. Benchmarks are reported as aggregates of the peer group, such as percentiles and medians, with the number of clubs reporting. No individual club’s compensation is ever disclosed.

What is the Workforce Profile and when is it available?

The Workforce Profile benchmarks turnover, tenure, overtime and staffing composition against peer clubs. It is coming soon to the Compensation & Benefits section of the platform for Summit subscribers, built from each club’s Payroll Report.

Does an Executive Compensation Study set pay?

No. Both the Executive Compensation Report and the Advanced Compensation Study quantify market value and state a clear conclusion, but the decision stays with the Board. The Advanced Compensation Study goes a step further and recommends that the Board adopt and document a compensation philosophy with a target percentile range.

Fact over opinion on compensation

Know what the market pays before you decide

Tell us what decision is in front of you, an open role, a payroll budget or a contract review, and we’ll show you the right way to benchmark it.

Book a meeting with our team See plans & pricing