Every budget season, some version of the same suggestion reaches the boardroom: let's give the members a year off from a dues increase. It is an understandable instinct. Members have watched their dues rise, some have just paid an assessment, and the Board wants to show it is listening. But the annual operating dues decision is the single most consequential number a Board sets, and holding the line on dues does not hold the line on costs.
In this whitepaper, Club Benchmarking CEO Dr. Jim Butler draws on more than a decade of operating data to answer the question members ask most often: if inflation is running around 3%, why do dues need to go up more than 3%? The short answer is that a club is not a household. Payroll and benefits take about 59 cents of every operating dollar, and the cost of one full-time club employee rose 30.4% from 2019 to 2025, about five points faster than the national Employment Cost Index. From 2013 to 2025, the cost of serving one member at the median club rose about 60% while CPI rose about 38%. Clubs kept up by raising dues faster than inflation. A club that had held its increases to CPI since 2013 would be collecting about 13.5% less in dues today, roughly $790,000 in 2025 alone at the median club.
The paper also looks at what dues are asked to support. In 2025 the median club's amenity subsidy was about $2.66 million, roughly half of operating dues revenue, and much of its growth came from the racquets, fitness, youth and family programs members asked for. A subsidy is not a sign of poor management. It is a choice about how to deliver the member experience, and the budgeting question is whether those choices are understood and funded.
Looking ahead, the next few years will be harder than the last few. Membership is growing less than 1% a year across the industry, so the dues rate will have to do the work that new members did during the post-COVID boom. The paper's starting guidance for 2027 is an operating dues increase of 5% to 6% at the median club to maintain the current experience, with planning ranges for every major expense line and insurance the outlier at 9% to 12%. It also shows why a skipped year is so costly: at a club with $5.9 million in dues, one skipped 5% increase adds up to about $3.71 million less over ten years.
The paper closes with practical guidance for presenting the increase in two pieces, Total Inflation and the Club Premium, and three questions every Board should be ready to answer. Members are customers, and they are also owners. The goal is a budget that funds the club they want to belong to, today and tomorrow.